Subscribe to the Seeking the Overlap podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Have you ever walked away from a conversation feeling unsure if the other person liked you as much as you liked them? Or maybe you’ve found yourself struggling to break out of your shell and make meaningful connections, even though you know how important they are. If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone—and more importantly, science can help explain why.
In episode 3 of Seeking the Overlap, I sat down with science writer David Robson, author of The Laws of Connection, to explore the challenges of forming authentic relationships and the often-overlooked barriers that hold us back. From understanding the hidden Liking Gap to learning how our relationships directly impact both our mental and physical health, this episode uncovers research-backed strategies for building stronger connections.
The Liking Gap: Why We Doubt Ourselves in Social Situations
One of the most intriguing insights David shared was around the concept of the Liking Gap. This term refers to the feeling many of us experience after a conversation—wondering whether the other person liked us as much as we liked them. According to David, this insecurity is incredibly common. Research shows that we tend to be overly critical of our own social interactions, assuming that others don’t enjoy our company as much as we enjoyed theirs. But in reality, they’re often thinking the exact same thing!
The Liking Gap is a powerful barrier that can stop us from pursuing deeper connections. By questioning whether we were truly liked, we may avoid following up, thus letting potential friendships fade before they even have a chance to grow. David’s message is simple: push through that doubt. In most cases, the other person is likely to feel the same sense of rapport as you did, and taking that small step toward nurturing the connection can make all the difference.
Social Connections and Your Health: More Than Just Happiness
While we often focus on the emotional benefits of having strong social bonds, David emphasized the critical role these relationships play in our physical health. In fact, studies have shown that the quality of our social connections is linked to diseases such as diabetes, heart disease, and even Alzheimer’s. It’s not just about feeling happy or fulfilled—these relationships have a tangible impact on how our bodies function.
Why is this? According to David, it all comes down to our evolutionary need for community. Historically, being part of a social group was essential for survival. When we feel excluded or isolated, our bodies react by increasing inflammation and blood clotting, as if preparing for physical injury. These responses were once crucial for survival, but in today’s world, chronic loneliness or isolation can take a heavy toll on our health.
As someone who’s experienced these effects firsthand, I can’t stress enough how true this is. During the times in my life when I felt most isolated, my physical and mental health both declined. Conversely, whenever I’ve been able to build a supportive community, I’ve seen my well-being improve dramatically.
Navigating Empathy and Vulnerability in Conversations
Another key topic we tackled was the delicate balance of self-disclosure in conversations. We’ve all been there—someone shares a personal story, and we’re tempted to respond with “Me too!” But how do you strike the right balance between empathy and making sure the conversation doesn’t become all about you?
David’s advice is simple: it’s all about nuance and timing. While sharing your own experiences can build trust and connection, it’s crucial to ensure that the other person feels heard first. Validate their feelings, ask curious questions, and be mindful not to dominate the conversation with your own story. When done thoughtfully, self-disclosure can strengthen relationships, but it’s important to make sure the other person remains the focus.
The Beautiful Mess Effect: Why Vulnerability Builds Stronger Bonds
One of the most powerful concepts David and I explored was the Beautiful Mess Effect. This idea turns our understanding of vulnerability on its head. We often fear that revealing our imperfections will drive people away, but research shows the opposite—people are drawn to honesty and authenticity.
Whether it’s admitting to a failure or sharing something deeply personal, vulnerability actually strengthens trust. David explained that by showing our “messy” side, we make ourselves more relatable and, ultimately, more likable. For recovering perfectionists like myself, this flies in the face of everything we’ve been taught. But the truth is, no one trusts perfection—people trust those who are real.
Takeaways: Building Stronger, More Authentic Relationships
So, how can we take these insights and start building deeper connections? Here are a few practical tips David shared:
Challenge the Liking Gap: Remind yourself that the other person likely enjoyed the conversation as much as you did. Don’t let self-doubt prevent you from following up and building on the connection.
Prioritize quality relationships: It’s not just about the number of people in your social circle—it’s about the quality. Invest in meaningful relationships that improve your well-being, both mentally and physically.
Use empathy in conversations: Strike a balance between sharing and listening. Validate the other person’s experience before diving into your own story.
Embrace vulnerability: Don’t be afraid to share your struggles and imperfections. Being real is what builds trust and deeper connections.
By understanding the science behind these social behaviors, we can overcome the barriers to connection and foster more fulfilling, authentic relationships.
Until next time, happy connecting!
Baily Hancock is a Connection Strategist, Keynote Speaker, and Host of the “Seeking the Overlap” Podcast who teaches people how to build, nurture, and leverage relationships to navigate challenges, thrive during transitions, and achieve greater success with the support of their community. Head to OverlapCollective.com to learn more, or comment below and say hello!
Share this post